B2
Dashboard
sg-star
Complete for 2 points

Deasbad mu thuathanas-gaoithe ann am Breacais

Debate about a wind farm in Breakish

Read this statement published on BBC Naidheachdan’s news website.

Tha luchd-leasachaidh a tha ag iarraidh tuathanas-gaoithe a stèidheachadh anns an Eilean Sgitheanach airson conaltradh ris a’ choimhearsnachd mu na planaichean.

Developers who want to establish a wind farm in Skye want to communicate with the community about the plans.

Thathas ag iarraidh 20 crann-gaoithe a chur suas faisg air Breacais.

It is proposed that 20 wind turbines be erected near Breakish.

Ach tha cuid de mhuinntir na coimhearsnachd air comataidh a chur air bhonn a tha a’ cur an aghaidh nam molaidhean.

But some people in the community have set up a committee which opposes the proposals.

Tha seo mar phàirt de ghrunn phlanaichean a tha san amharc a thaobh cumhachd ath-nuadhachail san eilean.

This is part of several planned plans for renewable energy in the island.

Nan rachadh cead a thoirt seachad do gach sgeama, bhiodh eadar 100 agus 150 crann-gaoithe mòr air feadh an eilein.

If permission were to be given to each scheme, there would be between 100 and 150 large wind turbines across the island.

Ach tha draghan air nochdadh gun toireadh obair-leasachaidh dhen t-seòrsa seo ann am Breacais buaidh air an àrainneachd ionadail, agus mar sin dheth gun toireadh e droch bhuaidh air gnìomhachas turasachd an eilein.

But concerns have emerged that development work of this type in Breakish would affect the local environment, and as such it would have a negative impact on the island’s tourism industry.

A rèir an fheadhainn a th’ air cùlaibh nam planaichean ge-tà tha conaltradh leis a’ choimhearsnachd aig cridhe a’ ghnothaich, agus thathas a’ dèanamh tòrr smaoineachaidh mu na làraichean as fheàrr mus bithear gan comharrachadh.

According to those behind the plans, however, communication with the community is at the heart of the matter, and a lot of thinking is taking place about the best sites before they are identified.

“Tha mi ag aithneachadh nan rachadh gach sgeama a cheadachadh gum biodh sin a’ cruthachadh fada a bharrachd cumhachd na tha feum air anns an eilean,” thuirt Steve Macken bho Lomond Energy.

“I recognise that if each scheme were to be approved that would create far more power than is needed in the island,” said Steve Macken from Lomond Energy.

“Ach ‘s e deagh rud a th’ anns a’ chothrom sin.

“But that opportunity is a good thing.

Mar sin dheth, tha e fìor chudromach dhuinne, mar luchd-leasachaidh, a bhith a’ dèanamh conaltraidh ri muinntir na sgìre agus fios a chumail riutha,” thuirt e.

Therefore, it is very important for us, as developers, to communicate with the people of the area and keep them informed,” he said.

Nam biodh tu a’ fuireach ann an àite far an togadh companaidh tuathanas-gaoithe, am biodh tu air a shon no na aghaidh?

If you lived in a place where a company would build a wind farm, would you be for it or against it?

Carson?

Why?

Dè na buannachdan a bhiodh na lùib?

What would be the advantages?

Dè na h-eas-bhuannachdan a bhiodh na lùib?

What would be the disadvantages?